A perspective for DMO boards and tourism leaders from Lee Forrest Consulting
Here is the honest answer heading into 2027. Influencers can bring people to your destination, but most DMOs have no way of knowing whether theirs did. The channel is not broken. The way most destinations buy it and measure it is.
That distinction matters because boards are being asked to approve bigger influencer budgets every year. Meanwhile, the people sitting on those boards still walk downtown on a Tuesday in shoulder season and wonder where all those "millions of impressions" went.
If you have ever felt that gap between the glowing report and the quiet street, this article is for you.
What 2026 actually told us
Destinations are still betting on influencers. According to Steller's 2026 State of Travel Influencer Marketing report, 92% of DMOs are holding or growing their influencer budgets this year. Nearly half increased spending, and only 7% cut back.
Travelers do say influencers matter, to a point. MMGY's Portrait of American Travelers found that 61% of active leisure travelers say influencers have at least some impact on their travel decisions.
But "some impact" is doing a lot of work in that sentence. When Omio and YouGov surveyed more than 7,500 travelers in April 2026, only 6% of U.S. travelers named influencers or online personalities as a factor in planning their trip. Personal interests, budget and ease of travel all ranked far higher.
And the trust picture is shifting. Coverage of Hilton's 2027 Trends report by Informa Connect in November 2026 suggests influencers are losing sway with everyday travelers, while 70% of travelers trust hotel staff as a planning resource. People with real local knowledge are winning the credibility contest.
Put those together and a pattern shows up. Influencers are good at sparking an idea. They are much weaker at closing the decision. That is not a reason to quit. It is a reason to be very clear about which job you are hiring them to do.
The vanity metric trap
Here is where the empty streets come from. The same Steller research shows 84% of destination marketers treat engagement as their top influencer KPI. Yet only 12% can track hotel bookings from social campaigns, and just 8% track trips planned. Three out of four said attribution is their single biggest challenge.
Now look at what boards and stakeholders actually want. Sojern's State of Destination Marketing 2026, based on more than 350 DMOs, found that 72% point to conversion and ROI metrics and 72% point to economic impact as the proof that matters most. Engagement came in a distant third at 41%. Sojern's own analysis adds that about half of DMOs struggle to tie campaigns to clear results.
So the industry is measuring likes while the people who approve budgets are asking about heads in beds. That is the gap.
Why does this keep happening? Because “likes” feel like progress. A big number on a slide gives everyone in the room a quick, comfortable signal that things are working. Our brains love a fast answer, and a follower count delivers one. The harder question, "did anyone actually come?", takes slower, more deliberate thinking and better data. Most reports are built to satisfy the first instinct, not the second.
Ten questions every DMO board should be asking
You do not need to be a marketer to hold an influencer program accountable. You just need to ask questions that move the conversation from activity to outcomes. Bring these to your next meeting.
- What job is this creator being hired to do? Awareness in a new market, filling a shoulder season and promoting a specific event are very different jobs, and each should be measured differently.
- Where does this creator's audience actually live? A million followers means little if most of them live on another continent or more than a day's travel away. Ask for the audience geography, not just the size.
- Does their audience match the visitor we want more of? Think length of stay, spending and season, not just age and interests.
- What did we measure besides engagement? Look for saves, link clicks, website sessions from target markets, branded search lift and partner booking data.
- Can we show a visitation lift? Location data providers now compare people who saw a campaign with a similar group who did not. Ask whether that was done, and if not, why.
- What would have happened if we had not run it? Without a comparison group or baseline, a busy month may simply have been a busy month.
- Do we own the content afterward? Content with full usage rights keeps working in ads, on the website and in email long after the post fades.
- What did it cost per real outcome? Cost per thousand views is easy. Cost per visit, cost per room night or cost per website lead from a target market is what matters.
- Which local businesses felt it? Ask hotels, attractions and restaurants named in the content whether they saw a change. Their front desk often knows before your dashboard does.
- What are we going to stop doing? A healthy program cuts the creators and formats that did not deliver. If nothing ever gets cut, nothing is really being measured.
Where the smarter money is going
If your influencer program cannot answer the questions above, the fix is not always to spend less. It is to spend with more intention and to strengthen the parts of the journey where decisions actually get made.
Become the answer, not just the ad
Travelers are asking AI tools where to go and what to do. A 2026 study by MMGY Intelligence, commissioned by Mindtrip, Sabre and Sojern, found that 40% of U.S. travelers have discovered a destination through AI and 29% have changed plans because of an AI recommendation. Yet only 26% of DMOs have a documented AI strategy. Future Partners data shows AI is the only trip planning channel gaining momentum, rising from 16.8% to 23.1% in a year.
These tools pull from content that honestly answers real traveler questions. What does it cost? Is it good for kids? What is parking like? What is there to do when it rains? Destinations that publish clear, candid answers to these questions become the source AI trusts. That builds credibility with travelers too, because people trust whoever answers their questions straight.
Turn your locals into the trusted voice
If 70% of travelers trust hotel staff, your front desk clerks, guides, bartenders and shop owners are some of your most persuasive marketers. Equip them with talking points, hidden gem lists and easy ways to share. Feature them in your content. A familiar local face lowers the perceived risk of choosing somewhere new, and lowering risk is often what tips a decision.
Build the measurement before the campaign
The destinations that can prove impact set it up in advance. In one example reported by Informa Connect in September 2026, a U.S. tourism board's campaign produced a 7.5% lift in visitors, confirmed through a footfall study with a location data partner. Tourism Economics has used similar control group methods with Experience Scottsdale. Bake this into every major campaign, influencer or not.
Keep creators, but give them a real job
Influencers still earn a place when the job is specific. Favor local and regional creators whose audiences live in your drive and fly markets. Tie each partnership to one outcome, such as an event, a shoulder season or a new air route. Secure full rights so the content keeps working. Then judge them by visits and spending, not hearts.
Sell how the trip will feel
Travelers increasingly choose trips based on how they want to feel, and Hilton's spokesperson framed the opportunity as helping guests think about how they will feel long after they get home. Emotional outcomes are what people remember and recommend. Build your story around that feeling first, then show the activities that deliver it.
Let's find out what your influencer spend is really doing
Most DMO boards I talk with are not against influencers. They just want to know, with confidence, that the money is bringing people through the door. That is a fair ask, and it is answerable.
At Lee Forrest Consulting, I help destination leaders take an honest look at where their marketing dollars go, which efforts move real visitors, and where to shift investment for 2027. We start by understanding how your visitors actually decide, then build a plan around it.
If you are heading into budget season with more questions than answers, let's talk. Book a consultative call and we will walk through your current program together, no pressure and no jargon.
Sources
- Travel destination marketers boost influencer budgets even as attribution gaps persist (Net Influencer, on Steller's 2026 State of Travel Influencer Marketing Report)
- Sojern State of Destination Marketing 2026 (Hotel Management)
- A Complete Guide to Proving Destination Marketing ROI (Sojern, July 2026)
- S. Travelers Aren't Pulling Back (MMGY Portrait of American Travelers, January 2026)
- Most travellers ignore social media hype when planning trips (PAX News, on the Omio and YouGov study, 2026)
- Are Travel Influencers Losing Their Sway? (Informa Connect, November 2026)
- The Hardest Destination Marketing Metric to Prove (Informa Connect, September 2026)
- Destination PR and AI recommendations (5W PR, on the MMGY, Mindtrip, Sabre and Sojern 2026 study)
- When Search Splits in Two (Think Digital Travel, 2026)
Frequently Asked Questions
Should our DMO stop working with influencers in 2027?
Not necessarily. Influencers still work well for building awareness in new markets and promoting specific events or seasons. The change is to give each partnership one clear job and judge it by visits and spending rather than likes.
How can we tell if an influencer campaign actually brought visitors?
Use location data to compare people who saw the campaign with a similar group who did not. Add tracked links, partner booking codes and branded search lift. Set all of this up before the campaign starts, because it is very hard to add afterward.
Why does AI search matter for a DMO?
More travelers now ask AI tools where to go and what to do there. Those tools favor clear, honest answers to real traveler questions. If your destination publishes those answers, you are far more likely to be the one recommended.
Are micro-influencers better than big names for destinations?
Often, yes, when their followers live in your drive and fly markets. A smaller creator whose audience can realistically visit is usually worth more than a large creator whose followers are scattered around the world.
What should a board expect in an influencer report?
Audience location, reach in target markets, website visits from those markets, cost per visit or room night where possible, and a short note on what will change next time. Engagement can be included, but it should not be the headline.
How much of our budget should go to influencers?
There is no universal number. Start with what you can measure. Fund the creators and formats that can show real outcomes, and shift the rest toward content, local ambassadors and measurement until the program can prove its value.
Why does AI search matter for a DMO?
A Fractional CMO provides objective executive supervision of audit channel performance, shuts down unsuccessful media initiatives, reallocates marketing budgets, and sets up sustainable content workflows.